The 5 Best Bakeries Around Harrisonburg

In this year’s Best of the Valley readers’ choice contest, voters made it clear: the Valley’s bakery scene offers much more than bread and bagels. From sweet treats and fresh donuts to artisan bagels and scratch-made pastries, these local spots satisfy every craving with quality ingredients and community spirit. Whether you’re after a quick breakfast or something special for the table, the following bakeries rose to the top in the hearts (and stomachs) of local residents.

Mr. J’s Bagels & Deli has long been a go-to for bagel lovers across its multiple Harrisonburg locations. Known for boiling and baking their bagels the traditional way, Mr. J’s offers an array of options, from classic plain and everything bagels to specialty creations. Beyond bagels, their menu includes deli sandwiches, salads, and breakfast platters, all served in a casual, friendly setting that keeps regulars coming back.

Overlook Produce, Bakery & Deli in Mount Crawford combines farm-fresh produce with scratch-made baked goods and deli offerings. Their bakery section features everything from pies and cookies to breads and cakes, often using local ingredients. Visitors appreciate the combination of a country market vibe with the attention to detail in every baked item, making it a popular stop for both weekly groceries and special occasions.

Strite’s Donuts is a local institution, known for hot, fresh donuts that are often served right from their food truck or downtown location. With recipes honed over decades, Strite’s offers yeast-raised and cake donuts with classic toppings like cinnamon sugar and glaze. Their commitment to freshness is central to their appeal, and locals know to arrive early for the best selection.

Chicken Scratch Bakery in Broadway specializes in homemade treats prepared in small batches. Their offerings include cookies, cakes, cupcakes, and seasonal specialties, each crafted with care. The bakery emphasizes using high-quality ingredients and creating desserts that not only taste good but also feel like something you’d bake at home—if you had the time and talent.

Moxie33 Coffee Co. in McGaheysville brings together locally roasted coffee and fresh-baked goods in a cozy café atmosphere. Their bakery case features muffins, scones, and pastries designed to pair perfectly with their coffee and espresso drinks. Moxie33 focuses on fostering community through good food, good coffee, and friendly service.

These bakeries show that when Best of the Valley voters choose a favorite, they’re recognizing more than just baked goods—they’re celebrating businesses that bring comfort, quality, and a touch of sweetness to daily life.

Thanks, ChatGPT.