The 5 Best Burgers Around Harrisonburg

n this year’s Best of the Valley readers’ choice contest, burger lovers showed just how passionate they are about the perfect patty. From classic beef burgers with all the fixings to unique takes that blend global flavors, these local favorites earned high praise for quality, creativity, and service. Whether you’re after a simple cheeseburger or a loaded specialty creation, these spots deliver bites that are worth the trip.

Old 33 Beer & Burger Grill in Elkton is known for pairing juicy burgers with a great beer selection in a relaxed setting. Their menu features classic and specialty burgers, all made to order and served alongside crispy fries or tots. With friendly service and a casual atmosphere, Old 33 has become a local go-to for burger fans looking to kick back with good food and good company.

Billy Jack’s Shack in Harrisonburg has built a reputation for creative burgers with bold flavors. Known for its fun, laid-back vibe, Billy Jack’s offers signature burgers that often feature unique toppings and house sauces. Pair your burger with their famous sticky nuggs or local draft beers for a meal that hits all the right notes.

Old School Burgers in Weyers Cave brings a no-nonsense approach to burger making. Focused on classic flavors and quality ingredients, Old School Burgers serves up patties cooked just right, with traditional toppings and a side of nostalgia. Locals appreciate the straightforward menu, fair prices, and friendly service.

Cuban Burger in Harrisonburg puts a flavorful twist on the classic American burger. Their signature Cuban-style beef patties are seasoned and seared to perfection, served on soft buns with toppings like Swiss cheese and pickles. Known for bold flavors and quick service, Cuban Burger offers a fresh alternative for those craving something a little different.

Micali’s Trattoria in Stuarts Draft may be known for Italian fare, but its burger offering stands out. Crafted with care and high-quality ingredients, the burger at Micali’s combines classic American comfort with attention to detail that reflects the restaurant’s overall approach to food. It’s a hidden gem for those who want a great burger alongside other made-from-scratch dishes.

These burger spots show why Best of the Valley voters take their burgers seriously—each offers satisfying options that blend quality, taste, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Thanks, ChatGPT.