The 5 Best Ice Cream Shops Around Harrisonburg

Few things bring joy like a scoop of creamy, cold delight—and in this year’s Best of the Valley readers’ choice contest, voters honored ice cream makers who hit the sweet spot between flavor, quality, and nostalgia. From handcrafted scoops to old-fashioned treats, these spots deliver smiles one cone at a time.

Smiley’s Ice Cream crafts small-batch ice cream using local, seasonal ingredients whenever possible. Known for inventive flavors—think peach, blackberry, and honey lavender—Smiley’s stands out for its rich textures and rotating menu that keeps fans coming back to taste what’s new and delicious.

Flotzie’s Soft Serve brings creamy soft serve, milkshakes, and sundaes with a classic twist. At community fairs and local events, Flotzie’s truck delights generations with nostalgic flavors and unfussy treats—just what you crave on hot summer afternoons.

Kline’s Dairy Bar delivers hometown charm with traditional scoops in cones and dishes. Known for consistently creamy favorites, Kline’s is a nostalgic stop where locals and travelers alike line up for a sweet treat that tastes just like summer did when they were kids.

The Udder Scoop delights with homemade ice cream served up with a side of friendly banter. With generous portions and heartfelt service, they keep automobiling fans smiling—literally.

These ice cream makers reflect what Best of the Valley voters love most: real ingredients, comforting flavors, and friendly service—delivered in cones, cups, and scoops that taste like memories.

Thanks, ChatGPT.