The 5 Best Sandwiches Around Harrisonburg

Sandwich lovers know a great sub is about more than bread—it’s harmony between fillings, fresh ingredients, and flavor that satisfies. In this year’s Best of the Valley readers’ choice contest, voters celebrated delis and cafés that deliver well-balanced bites, quality meats and veggies, and friendly service. These spots make every lunch or afternoon break feel intentional—and delicious.

Mr. J’s Bagels & Deli builds robust sandwiches from scratch‑made bagels or hearty rolls, piled high with deli meats, cheeses, and crisp produce. Their weekday breakfast and lunchtime rush shows how much locals appreciate their fresh‑and-fast sandwiches. It's where early meetings and midday cravings both find a perfect match.

Overlook Produce, Bakery & Deli combines scratch‑baked breads, house‑made spreads, and market‑fresh toppings. Customers can customize every layer—whether they’re building a turkey club or a veggie delight. With grab‑and‑go convenience and made‑to‑order care, this spot feels like a small‑town deli done right.

Sunrise Market Deli delivers classic deli favorites—think Reubens, Italian subs, and cold‑cut platters—made with thick‑cut meats and old‑school charm. Their counter service and neat paper‑wrapped sandwiches evoke nostalgia, fueling repeat visits from fans who want comfort in every bite.

Lola’s Delicatessen goes gourmet with curated combos like roast beef with horseradish aioli or grilled veggie with pesto and goat cheese—all served on artisan bread. Their thoughtful pairings and rotating seasonal specials make each visit feel like discovery, with flavors that stand out.

The Cheese Place elevates the sandwich into an art form with craft cheeses, charcuterie, and house‑made condiments. Think brie and apple on sourdough or prosciutto with fig jam. Their shop‑to‑table offerings feel upscale yet approachable—perfect for a lunch you’d actually look forward to.

These sandwich shops reflect what Best of the Valley voters appreciate most: fresh ingredients, balanced flavors, and service that gives lunchtime a reason to smile. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or lingering over a late-afternoon bite, these spots deliver something delicious, every time.

Thanks, ChatGPT.